1810-1910: semejanzas y diferencias
Through a combination of the cross-case method of compari- son (more typical of sociology) and the cross-temporal method (more typical of history), the essay seeks to construct a range of similarities and differences between the Independence movement and the Mexican Revolution, primarily by look...
| Autor principal: | |
|---|---|
| Formato: | Online |
| Idioma: | espanhol |
| Editor: |
El Colegio de México, A.C.
2009
|
| Assuntos: | |
| Acesso em linha: | https://historiamexicana.colmex.mx/index.php/RHM/article/view/1807 |
| Recursos: |
Historia Mexicana |
| authentication_code | dc |
|---|---|
| _version_ | 1853488662570860544 |
| author | Van Young, Eric |
| author_facet | Van Young, Eric |
| author_sort | Van Young, Eric |
| category_str_mv |
"Bolivia", "hyperinflation", "economic crisis", "Bolivia", "hiperinflación", "crisis económica"
|
| collection | OJS |
| description | Through a combination of the cross-case method of compari- son (more typical of sociology) and the cross-temporal method (more typical of history), the essay seeks to construct a range of similarities and differences between the Independence movement and the Mexican Revolution, primarily by looking at the participation of indigenous common people in each upheaval. Three major variables are selected for comparison: ethnicity, the role of the community, and religious sensibility. These three variables are not isolated, however, but are inter-dependent, since late colonial villages were defined not only by ethnicity, but also by localist (community) loyalties, localism was reinforced and even built upon religious practice, and religious belief and practice in large measure were shaped by the nature of ethnicity. The conclusions are that the Mexican Independence movement was much more Indian, more intensely localist, and more religious in tone than the revolution of a century later. It is only with the Revolution that signs of a nationalist sensibility begin to appear among common people. |
| format | Online |
| id | oai:oai.historiamexicana.colmex.mx:article-1807 |
| index_str_mv | CONAHCYT LATINDEX PKP Index DOAJ DORA Redalyc Scielo México CLASE Handbook of Latin American Studies (HLAS) JSTOR Sociological Abstracts EBSCO Host HAPI HELA Scopus Ulrich’s International Periodicals Directory CIRC CSA Worldwide Political Science Abstracts Google Scholar Historical Abstracts IBSS MLA Biblat Current Abstracts Elektronische Zeitschriftenbibliothek Frei zugängliche ERIH PLUS IBZ Gale OneFile: Informe Académico Journal Scholar Metrics (EC3 Research Group: Evaluación de la Ciencia y la Comunicación Científica. Universidad de Granada) Periodicals Index Online America History and Life Global Issues in Context IBR Index Islamicus InfoTracCustom International Bibliography of Sociology Political Science Complete PubMed Social Services Abstracts SocINDEX SocINDEX with Full Text TOC Premier Anthropological Index Online Arts and Humanities Citation Index Chicano Periodical Index Current Contents CWTS Journal Indicators e-Revistas Humanities International Complete Humanities International Index Humanities Source PERIODICA Russian Academy of Sciences Bibliographies SCImago Journal & Country Rank |
| journal | Historia Mexicana |
| language | spa |
| publishDate | 2009 |
| publisher | El Colegio de México, A.C. |
| record_format | ojs |
| Terms_governing_use_and_reproduction_note | Derechos de autor 2016 Historia Mexicana |
| data_source_entry/ISSN | Historia Mexicana; Vol. 59, Núm. 1 (233) julio-septiembre 2009; 389-441 2448-6531 0185-0172 |
| spelling | oai:oai.historiamexicana.colmex.mx:article-18072022-04-19T19:25:21Z 1810-1910: resemblances and differences 1810-1910: semejanzas y diferencias Van Young, Eric Mexico wars identity nationalism revolution independence 19th Century 20th Century México guerras identidad nacionalismo revolución independencia siglo XIX siglo XX Through a combination of the cross-case method of compari- son (more typical of sociology) and the cross-temporal method (more typical of history), the essay seeks to construct a range of similarities and differences between the Independence movement and the Mexican Revolution, primarily by looking at the participation of indigenous common people in each upheaval. Three major variables are selected for comparison: ethnicity, the role of the community, and religious sensibility. These three variables are not isolated, however, but are inter-dependent, since late colonial villages were defined not only by ethnicity, but also by localist (community) loyalties, localism was reinforced and even built upon religious practice, and religious belief and practice in large measure were shaped by the nature of ethnicity. The conclusions are that the Mexican Independence movement was much more Indian, more intensely localist, and more religious in tone than the revolution of a century later. It is only with the Revolution that signs of a nationalist sensibility begin to appear among common people. Mediante la combinación del método comparativo intercaso (más típico de la sociología) y el método intertemporal (más típico de la historia), este ensayo busca establecer una serie de similitudes y diferencias entre el movimiento de independencia y la revolución mexicana, considerando en primera instancia la participación de la gente común indígena en cada levantamiento. Se eligieron tres variables principales para la comparación: la etnicidad, el papel de la comunidad y la sensibilidad religiosa. Estas variables, empero, no están aisladas, sino que son interdependientes, pues los pueblos de finales de la colonia se definían no sólo por la etnicidad, sino por las lealtades localistas (comunidad), el localismo se fortalecía e incluso se construía con base en la práctica religiosa y las creencias y prácticas religiosas se configuraban en torno de la naturaleza de la etnicidad. El ensayo concluye que el movimiento de independencia fue mucho más indígena, más intensamente localista y de un tono más religioso que la Revolución un siglo después, y que sólo con la Revolución comenzaron a aparecer señales de una sen- sibilidad nacionalista entre la gente común. El Colegio de México, A.C. 2009-07-01 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://historiamexicana.colmex.mx/index.php/RHM/article/view/1807 Historia Mexicana; Vol. 59, Núm. 1 (233) julio-septiembre 2009; 389-441 2448-6531 0185-0172 spa https://historiamexicana.colmex.mx/index.php/RHM/article/view/1807/1625 Derechos de autor 2016 Historia Mexicana |
| spellingShingle | Mexico wars identity nationalism revolution independence 19th Century 20th Century México guerras identidad nacionalismo revolución independencia siglo XIX siglo XX Van Young, Eric 1810-1910: semejanzas y diferencias |
| title | 1810-1910: semejanzas y diferencias |
| title_alt | 1810-1910: resemblances and differences |
| title_full | 1810-1910: semejanzas y diferencias |
| title_fullStr | 1810-1910: semejanzas y diferencias |
| title_full_unstemmed | 1810-1910: semejanzas y diferencias |
| title_short | 1810-1910: semejanzas y diferencias |
| title_sort | 1810 1910 semejanzas y diferencias |
| topic | Mexico wars identity nationalism revolution independence 19th Century 20th Century México guerras identidad nacionalismo revolución independencia siglo XIX siglo XX |
| topic_facet | Mexico wars identity nationalism revolution independence 19th Century 20th Century México guerras identidad nacionalismo revolución independencia siglo XIX siglo XX |
| url | https://historiamexicana.colmex.mx/index.php/RHM/article/view/1807 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT vanyoungeric 18101910resemblancesanddifferences AT vanyoungeric 18101910semejanzasydiferencias |